.
[An excerpt reprinted
from the Henry George News, May 1957.
Originally published in Land &
Liberty, September, 1939] |
On 1st September the German army invaded Poland. On Sunday,
3rd September, the Governments of Great Britain and France declared war
on the Government of Germany, and the British Dominions have since
joined in. People speak of the war as a terrible calamity, which it is,
but calamity is a word that only appropriately describes a disaster
which mankind can neither foresee nor avert, like an earthquake or a
deluge or other convulsion of nature.
It is lamentable to look back upon the twenty-five years of the
armistice and to notice the follies of statesmanship in this and in
other countries in the economic field. We leave to others the political
and the diplomatic, only wishing that they would not so ignore the
association of poverty with their problems. It was a Germany in distress
that produced Hitler the demagogue who could inflame the passion of his
mobs against the alleged oppressors beyond the borders of Germany. Given
any country that has been defeated in war and with 10,000,000
unemployed, the demagogue has his stage ready made for him if he wants
to blame the foreigner; yet that poverty and unemployment in Germany had
as much and as little to do with the Versailles Treaty (admitting its
faults) as the poverty and unemployment in this country or in the United
States. It had, however, everything to do with land speculation and the
world-wide industrial depression that followed upon the boom period
immediately succeeding the war. By 1929 the tariff walls that all the
nations had built up and had raised ever higher were operating with full
effect to prevent recovery. But the mad policy was not abandoned. It was
pursued still further by expedients like the Ottawa agreements creating
privileges in British markets against the rest of the world, by quotas,
restrictions, subsidies and exchange controls which in Germany found
their logical and complete expression in the State dictatorship of trade
and production called autarchy...
In 1927 at the Geneva Economic Conference we discovered the obstacles
that stood in the way of the lowering of tariffs and the influences that
sought to increase them. They are not alone the protected manufacturers.
Far more powerful and determined is the great financial interest in
exemption from taxation and the transference of the burden upon the
working people. For the sake of that interest, indirect taxation must be
preserved at all costs and the protectionist system upheld.
The frontiers that were created out of the Versailles Treaty were not
the cause of trouble. They would not have mattered the least bit if
trade had been allowed to flow freely over and across them. But tariffs
were erected on either side of these boundaries between states. The
devilish invention for enabling some people to rob the rest of the
people has interlaced Europe with a series of barbed wire fences and
converted customs houses to pill boxes. War was the natural and
inevitable outcome. If the barriers are not lifted by peaceful means,
they invite the use of artillery to smash a way through.
|